“The Bold and the Beautiful” Bombshell: Could Finn Be Hiding a Killer Instinct?

“The Bold and the Beautiful” Bombshell: Could Finn Be Hiding a Killer Instinct?

April 17, 2025 | Soap Scene Weekly by TV Pulse

In the glamorous world of The Bold and the Beautiful, where love and betrayal walk hand in hand, one character may be headed down a dangerously dark path. Could the charming and compassionate Dr. John “Finn” Finnegan be harboring a secret so twisted, it could cost Liam Spencer his life?

It’s a hypothetical storyline that has fans buzzing — and if it unfolds, it could mark one of the most shocking transformations in daytime television history.

The Perfect Man… or the Perfect Cover?

Since his debut, Finn has been the image of the ideal man: devoted to Steffy Forrester, loving father to Hayes, and a respected doctor. But beneath that calm, noble façade lies a haunting legacy — his biological connection to the infamous Sheila Carter.

The revelation that Sheila is his mother stunned viewers and characters alike. Though Finn has repeatedly distanced himself from her chaos, fans can’t help but wonder: Has Sheila’s darkness found a way into her son’s soul?

After all, Sheila didn’t hesitate to shoot both Finn and Steffy in a fit of obsession. Yet Finn still saved her life. His boundless empathy may seem admirable… or is it a sign of something more unstable?

A Rivalry Brewing in Silence

At the center of this brewing storm is Liam Spencer, Steffy’s ex, and father of her daughter, Kelly. Liam has never truly stepped out of Steffy’s life — or out of Finn’s shadow. Their triangle has long simmered beneath the surface, flaring during Steffy’s pregnancy when questions swirled about the baby’s paternity.

Even after it was confirmed that Hayes was Finn’s son, Liam’s interference didn’t stop. In 2023, he spent months accusing Finn of endangering Steffy due to his connection to Sheila. Though partially justified, Liam’s constant meddling could easily be seen as a threat — not just to Finn’s relationship, but to his very identity as Steffy’s protector.

What if Finn’s frustration has quietly reached its boiling point?

Murder in the Operating Room: A Chilling Possibility

The hypothetical scenario? A surgical procedure — and a deliberate act of sabotage.

As a doctor, Finn holds a position of immense trust. He has access to powerful medications, knowledge of the human body, and most importantly, the skill to make a murder look like a medical accident. If he were to eliminate Liam during surgery, no one would suspect a thing — at first.

Such a turn would echo the legacy of Sheila Carter, the master manipulator who has left decades of destruction in her wake. Finn crossing the line from healer to killer would mark a terrifying full-circle moment — and a betrayal that could shatter Steffy’s world.

Steffy’s Breaking Point: Love, Lies, and Legacy

Throughout their relationship, Steffy has stood by Finn. Even when the truth about Sheila emerged, she defended him, believing that nature didn’t define nurture. But if Finn were revealed as Liam’s killer — if he used his medical license as a weapon — everything would change.

Steffy, a survivor of betrayal, loss, and violence, would likely sever all ties. She could take Hayes and walk away, determined to protect her son from the darkness that claimed his father. Her heartbreak would be immense — not just for the man she loved, but for the future she thought she had secured.

Redemption or Ruin?

If exposed, Finn would face more than legal consequences — he’d be forced to confront the monster within. Would he seek redemption through therapy, apologies, and public penance? Or would he embrace the darker legacy Sheila left behind, becoming a new villain for the ages?

This scenario opens up a whirlwind of dramatic possibilities: custody battles, courtroom showdowns, and a potential war between the Forrester and Logan families. Liam’s connection to Hope Logan would drag her family into the fray, while Ridge Forrester, protective as ever, would rally around his daughter with fierce determination.

The Inheritance of Evil?

Perhaps the most haunting question this storyline raises is whether evil can be inherited. Finn was raised in a loving, stable home — but is blood destiny? If Sheila’s violent impulses can resurface in Finn, what about Hayes?

Could Steffy’s son grow up to inherit the very same darkness that claimed both his grandmother and father?

A Star Turn for Tanner Novlan?

For actor Tanner Novlan, a villain arc would be a thrilling opportunity to explore new emotional depths. From compassionate hero to calculating antihero, such a transformation could cement Finn as one of the most layered and unpredictable characters in Bold history.

A Soap Opera Legacy

From unexpected deaths to shocking betrayals, The Bold and the Beautiful has never shied away from high drama. A potential fall from grace for Finn would only continue this tradition — blending the show’s signature glamour with a chilling psychological twist.

For now, this remains a speculative storyline — but in the world of daytime drama, anything is possible. And sometimes, the darkest turns make for the most unforgettable television.