Days of our lives spoilers: RUMOR! James Scott returns as EJ and Dan Feuerriege is leaving DOOL.

James Scott to Return as EJ DiMera? Rumors Swirl as Dan Feuerriegel’s Exit Shakes Up Days of Our Lives

By TV Drama Digest

In the ever-twisting world of Days of Our Lives, few rumors have electrified the fanbase quite like this one: James Scott, the iconic actor behind the original EJ DiMera, may be returning to Salem—and possibly at the expense of current EJ actor Dan Feuerriegel. Could this be the ultimate soap opera shocker, or just a fan-fueled fantasy? Let’s dig into the swirling speculation.

The Return That Could Rock Salem

James Scott left Days in 2014 after an unforgettable run as the suave, conflicted, and at times dangerous Elvis “EJ” DiMera. His chemistry with Alison Sweeney’s Sami Brady and his intense internal struggle between villainy and redemption made him a standout star in the DiMera dynasty.

Now, more than a decade later, fans are buzzing that Scott could be making his grand return—either to reclaim the role of EJ or to portray a brand-new DiMera character. The idea gained traction online, particularly across platforms like Reddit and X (formerly Twitter), where devoted viewers began stitching together hints from interviews, backstage leaks, and their own dreams of a James Scott comeback.

The possibility of Scott stepping back into EJ’s designer shoes sent shockwaves through the Days fandom. For some, it would be a triumphant homecoming. For others, it raises uncomfortable questions—particularly about what it means for Dan Feuerriegel, who has portrayed EJ since 2021.

“James Scott is EJ, no question,” one fan posted, “but Dan’s doing a great job. Why mess with that?”

A New DiMera? Fresh Faces, Old Legacies

Among the wilder fan theories: What if Scott isn’t returning as EJ at all—but as a new character entirely? Could he play Vincent DiMera, a secret son of the late Stefano DiMera? A figure raised in the shadows, trained to uphold the DiMera legacy with even more ruthless precision than EJ or Chad?

Picture this: Vincent arrives in Salem under a veil of mystery, harboring cutting-edge tech that could resurrect Stefano himself—via AI, brain chips, or something even more sinister. This would ignite chaos in the DiMera family, pitting him against both EJ (still played by Feuerriegel) and the rest of the clan.

It’s pure soap opera gold—and exactly the kind of high-stakes drama fans live for.

Resurrecting Stefano DiMera: A Phoenix Reborn?

The other half of this rumor centers on a possible resurrection of the DiMera patriarch himself—Stefano. Originally portrayed by the late, great Joseph Mascolo, Stefano remains one of the most legendary villains in soap opera history.

Despite his confirmed death in 2016, Stefano has “risen from the ashes” multiple times through fake deaths, impersonators, brainwashing, and even AI—so it’s not outlandish to imagine another return. Pairing that return with James Scott’s reappearance? That’s the kind of twist that would bring longtime viewers back in droves.

Imagine a secret DiMera vault containing Stefano’s consciousness… a digital Phoenix waiting to be unleashed.

“If James Scott comes back and brings Stefano with him? I’m canceling all my plans to watch,” a fan gushed on X.

But Is It All Just a Rumor?

Unfortunately, reality tempers the excitement. Despite the storm of speculation, Days of Our Lives producers have made no official announcements about Scott’s return. Neither press releases nor cast teasers have hinted at any such development. And Scott himself has remained silent—unsurprising, given that he stepped away from acting in 2014 and has since built a life as a professional life coach.

In interviews, Scott has expressed peace with his decision to leave Hollywood behind.

“Acting was an incredible ride, but I’m where I’m meant to be now,” he told one publication in 2017.

Still, the absence of evidence hasn’t stopped fans from holding out hope. After all, in the world of soaps, the line between fiction and reality is always a little blurred.

Nostalgia vs. Progress: The Heart of the Debate

At its core, this rumor taps into something deeper than just casting choices. It’s about the emotional connection fans have to characters like EJ and Stefano. James Scott’s EJ was more than just a leading man—he was a symbol of an era. His return would mark a reconnection to Days’ golden years, when love, betrayal, and DiMera family drama ruled the screen.

Still, fans are torn. Some argue that the show must move forward with a new generation. Others say nostalgia is exactly what Days needs to survive. Either way, it’s a debate that speaks to the heart of daytime TV’s enduring appeal: the delicate dance between evolution and tradition.

“I’d give anything to see James Scott back as EJ,” wrote one fan, “but if he’s happy as a life coach, I’m happy for him.”

“Stephano’s story feels done without Joseph Mascolo. Let the Phoenix rest,” added another.

Final Thoughts: Could the Phoenix Rise Again?

So, is James Scott really returning to Days of Our Lives? As of now, it remains an unconfirmed—albeit fascinating—rumor. But its impact is undeniable. It shows how deeply fans still care about these characters, how much the legacy of actors like James Scott and Joseph Mascolo continues to matter.

Whether the Phoenix rises once more or the rumors fade like a dream, one thing is clear: Days of Our Lives continues to be a soap opera where anything is possible, and the next big twist is always just around the corner.

What Do You Think?

Would you welcome James Scott back as EJ—or a new DiMera entirely? Should Days bring back Stefano in some form, or let his legacy rest in peace? Let us know your wildest theories and dream storylines.